A few weeks ago, my students and I discussed a local drug company’s new LEED platinum building. The building was the first to be given the highest level of certification for environmental performance by the US Green Business Council. By building it, the drug company received voluminous and tremendously positive press coverage. And yet, the more my class and I looked into it, the more we doubted the building’s merits.
According to the information we could obtain, several of the credits needed to boost the LEED certification from Gold to platinum came from additional steps to conserve water and use green power. Although water and energy conservation seem praiseworthy, the real question that should be asked by anyone interested in sustainability is: “do these investments improve total human happiness?” And according to our calculation, in the case of this building the answer was an emphatic “NO!” The building’s carbon reductions were obtained at a cost more than double that required to purchase carbon offsets. Similarly, the water savings turned out to cost a little less than $4 per thousand gallons – a number comparable to the most inefficient means of producing fresh water. By our calculation, the drug company could have achieved the same energy and water objectives at a lower cost and had some money left over to give back to its investors – many of whom have been upset by the firm’s recent poor financial performance.
If the managers of this company really wanted to spend the same amount of money in improving social welfare, how should they have spent it? By using their comparative advantage in drug discovery to find drugs for neglected diseases, we concluded. For example, they could have invested more money in programs to find cures for diseases like Malaria or tuberculosis which are of growing concern worldwide. In fact, the company has a program to do just this, but its annual budget is a fraction of the money required to push their building over the LEED platinum threshold.
My class and I concluded that just as we should criticize firms for inefficiently failing to seize profitable ways to reduce their effect on the environment, so should we castigate them for spending money wastefully to reduce their environmental impact. A firm deserves praise, we concluded when it tries to maximize human happiness, and not when it acts not to reduce energy consumption at any cost.
Unfortunately, not all stakeholders respond as economists think they should, and as I mentioned earlier, the building was widely praised. When I asked a local elected official about this at a recent dinner party, her response was “But being the first platinum building made a big difference to city officials. The company got a lot of good will.” I said, “But wouldn’t they have gotten as much good will for using the money to work on drug-resistant TB or malaria?” Her response was “No, they [local elected officials] don’t care at all about that.” This surprised me because drug resistant TB is already a health problem, and malaria may become one – particularly in low lying areas like my home town.
As economists and management scholars, we often assume that firms are acting in response to well-reasoned stakeholder demands. The resulting give and take between firms and stakeholders, we hope, brings about a situation where both parties are better off. But the story of this particular LEED building suggests that such interactions can also lead to wasteful outcomes. Under what conditions do good outcomes emerge from interactions between stakeholders and firms, and when and how do things go wrong? ARCS scholars like Tom Lyon (Michigan), John Maxwell (Indiana), Mike Lenox (Darden) and I are working on exactly this issue. We are beginning to understand when stakeholder pressure leads to good outcomes and when it leads to green washing and waste. More on that in my next post.
Interesting arguments. A few additional considerations:
1. Part of the premise of your argument is that sustainability ought to be exclusively human-focused, as evidenced by (“do these investments improve total human happiness?”). I think sustainability ought to also consider other species, both of which might be more enhanced by improving air and water quality.
2. Even if constrained to human happiness (which might be heavily weighted to the short-term) it’s hard to know off hand what benefits the marginal dollar would actually elicit for water and air quality vs. reducing disease.
3. A wise man once reminded me of the importance spillover effects. Such effects might well be present with investments in green building practices. If a green building signals something desirable about management, it could attract higher caliber workers and venture partners. And green buildings might actually deliver on their promise to enhance productivity via better indoor air quality. If these effects take hold, either or both could actually enhance the productivity of drug discovery efforts.
Interesting points. Deconstructing construction?
Some observations/comments:
1. LEED is not meant to be sustainability in general. It is an environmental set of standards. Social and economic issues are not part of these standards. I have heard that many LEED certified buildings are some x% greater in cost (something like 15%, but don’t hold me to it). Also, whether slave labor or underpaid workers are supplying material or erecting the building is not relevant for the LEED requirements. Thus, the triple bottom line of sustainability is not an issue.
2. LEED is not anywhere near perfect, but it is better than nothing. There are attempts to improve the environmental performance of buildings, if nothing else, raising awareness of this activity. Builders are not laughing when they are asked about LEED and are seriously considering the environmental issues of the built environment. I think this is one of the ‘spillover’ effects Mike mentions. The benefits are not always very direct and tangible, as much as stockholders and investors would like.
3. There is another problem with LEED something that costs millions to do, gets as much credit as something that costs hundreds. There is no real ‘business’ or ‘environmental’ case associated with it. That is the costs are not really part (maybe they shouldn’t be?) of the LEED requirements, as mentioned. But there is also a poor balance of environmental criteria. Is putting up renewable energy systems the same as putting bike racks outside the door? LEED thinks so. The credits given are the same no matter the environmental or business (or social) impact.
4. What is greenwashing? It is a term that does not have a clear definition. Every organization causes some environmental degradation. I know of no organization that is inter-generationally sustainable for perpetuity. Thus, any organization that makes a claim, gets a certificate, etc. is greenwashing. But, at least they are making the effort. But, if everyone is greenwashing, it means very little. These things like LEED and other certifications are drops in a very big lake, but at least they are contributing in some way.
5. In the case of your project, some things may be considered poor decisions (e.g. a cheaper alternative) but we really don’t know what is causing the decision to have been made in a particular way. It could be because of the systemic aspects of construction (one aspect requiring a little more expense while another element more than makes up on savings). It could be because of poor management decisions or needing to get a quick solution. It could be because, as you assert, they didn’t talk to everyone, or the most critical stakeholders involved. Maybe the most critical stakeholder is the supplier who knows someone well on the management team? All these things take time and planning. Not all organizations are runperfectly and not all organizations (or people) are born knowing all. If this is a mistake economically, not sure that it is, then they learn from it. But is it a mistake environmentally? It’s a wash in that situation.
6. Carbon offsets? Do you trust those? Not sure if things are that easily calculated.
Mike
1. Part of the premise of your argument is that sustainability ought to be exclusively human-focused, as evidenced by (“do these investments improve total human happiness?”)…
a. Yes, this is my logic. Honestly, I can see no other. Even if we tried to follow some sort of Kantian Categorical Imperative, any other test would fail. Would we really wish to pass a general world-wide law (his first test for the CI) so that no species went extinct or that no changes were made to the planet? Does not having the law make logical sense (another test)? No. So, no principal beyond a utilitarian logic makes sense to me. We may want to preserve species because they increase human utility, but that is consistent with what I said.
2. Even if constrained to human happiness (which might be heavily weighted to the short-term) it’s hard to know off hand what benefits the marginal dollar would actually elicit for water and air quality vs. reducing disease.
a. One can never know exactly, but let us reverse the logic. Is there any reason to believe that the company had a comparative advantage in having a green building designed for it? Did it possess some unique knowledge or capabilities? No. Would a social planner have allocated resources to this company to have them make these investments? No. Now, consider its ability to develop drugs? I think the answer to both questions is YES.
3. A wise man once reminded me of the importance spillover effects. Such effects might well be present with investments in green building practices. If a green building signals something desirable about management, it could attract higher caliber workers and venture partners. And green buildings might actually deliver on their promise to enhance productivity via better indoor air quality. If these effects take hold, either or both could actually enhance the productivity of drug discovery efforts.
a. But then why certify? If workers like the building they will want to work there regardless of whether it is LEED Platinum or LEED plutonium. As to the “signaling” argument. That is the subject of my next blog.
I understand that we all want to hope that companies will save us from ourselves. And, I understand that cynicism and pessimism are dangerous perspectives. However, we must be careful not to fall for greenwashing and thereby reward counterproductive actions.
Interesting topic. Adding to Mike’s considerations, here a few
provocative thoughts.
1) I could be completely wrong but a brand new green building for many companies is a sign of power and a way to enhance the company’s
reputation especially in the local community. It is a truly marketing product. Is it a deceptive use of marketing? I am not sure. Pushing your argument to the extreme, we could say that the drug company should not waste money in expensive buildings or even in marketing, on the contrary they should solely focus on fighting illnesses and maximizing human happiness.
2) Had it been a Tobacco company would you make the same argument?
3) Another question would be whether LEED certification and eventually other types of green certifications are truly effective.
4) Looking back at your example, the proximity dimension could be interesting to explore in trying to understand whether stakeholder pressure leads to good or bad outcomes. What is good locally (the new fancy green building for the local
community) may not be necessarily good globally.
Andrew, are you including a temporal element to the logic of “maximizing human happiness” in your research? What makes people happy today may not tomorrow, and the results may be too late fix. Know what I mean–just curious.
That said, as one involved in the fee-based world of green and sustainable education and certification (and hopefully change-inducing) programs. The question of investment of dollars by our members to these efforts–especially investment of dollars for the assistance and oversight from a USGBC or other organization–is a constant internal question. As a mission-based organization, how do we affect the greatest amount of change? I guess I end up falling back on my friend Voltaire: “the perfect is the enemy of the good (paraphrased).”
Corporate sustainability, would you say that a Corporation such as UNFI and Steve Spinner that thinks if he just puts a couple of solar panels on a building, but refuses to respect his on workers right`s can claims to be a GREEN CO. or should I say a company that say it`s driven by sustainability.
Saya sudah lama menelusuri web selama 4 jam hari ini, tetapi saya belum menemukan artikel yang menarik seperti ini.
Pendapat saya, jika semua pemilik situs membuat konten sebagus
ini, web akan menjadi lebih berguna daripada sebelumnya.
|
Saya tidak bisa menahan diri untuk berkomentar. Tulisan ini sangat menarik!
|
Saya segera menyimpan RSS feed Anda karena saya tidak dapat menemukan tautan newsletter Anda.
Apakah Anda memiliki? Tolong beri tahu saya agar
saya bisa berlangganan. Terima kasih! |
Ini adalah waktu yang tepat untuk membuat rencana masa depan dan juga saatnya untuk berbahagia.
Saya telah membaca artikel ini dan jika saya boleh, saya ingin memberikan sedikit saran. Barangkali Anda
bisa menulis artikel selanjutnya yang berkaitan dengan topik ini.
Saya ingin membaca lebih banyak lagi! |
Ahaa, ini adalah pembahasan yang menarik tentang artikel ini di blog, saya sudah membaca semuanya,
jadi sekarang saya juga ingin berkomentar di sini! |
Saya yakin bahwa artikel ini telah menyentuh banyak pembaca online, ini benar-benar tulisan yang menarik
untuk membangun blog baru. |
Wow, artikel ini benar-benar informatif, saudara saya sedang belajar tentang
hal-hal seperti ini, jadi saya akan segera memberitahunya! |
Saya berterima kasih atas informasi yang menarik ini. Saya
sangat menikmati membaca artikel Anda dan saya berharap Anda terus menulis lebih banyak lagi!
|
Tulisan ini sangat informatif, saya akan sering kembali ke blog ini untuk
membaca lebih banyak lagi. |
Saya benar-benar menikmati membaca konten ini, saya harap
Anda terus berbagi lebih banyak artikel hebat seperti ini.
|
Benar-benar menyukai cara Anda menyusun artikel ini.
Penjelasannya jelas dan informasinya berguna. Terima
kasih! |
Terima kasih banyak atas konten yang luar biasa ini.
Saya pasti akan kembali untuk membaca lebih banyak artikel menarik di blog ini.
|
Tulisan ini sangat bagus! Saya menyukai bagaimana Anda menyampaikan topik ini dengan cara yang informatif.
|
Saya menikmati membaca konten ini! Terima kasih telah berbagi informasi yang sangat menarik.
|
Blog ini benar-benar informatif dan penuh wawasan! Saya akan sering kembali untuk membaca lebih banyak artikel seperti ini.
|
Hebat sekali! Saya sangat menghargai usaha yang telah Anda lakukan dalam menyusun artikel ini.
|
Saya sangat berterima kasih atas artikel ini! Ini sangat membantu
saya dalam memahami lebih jauh tentang topik ini. |
Saya sangat menikmati bagaimana Anda menjelaskan konsep ini dengan begitu detail.
|
Tulisan ini sungguh berguna. Saya berharap Anda terus berbagi lebih banyak lagi!
|
Saya akan merekomendasikan halaman ini kepada teman-teman saya!
Ini benar-benar sumber informasi yang berharga.
|
Sungguh luar biasa! Terima kasih sudah berbagi wawasan yang sangat berguna.
|
Saya mendapatkan artikel ini. Saya sangat menghargai telah membagikannya.
|
Topik ini sungguh menambah wawasan! Saya ingin membaca
lebih banyak lagi artikel seperti ini. |
Saya senang menemukan blog ini! Informasinya begitu berguna.
|
Sungguh luar biasa! Artikel ini benar-benar membantu saya memahami lebih dalam tentang topik ini.
|
Saya mengapresiasi artikel ini! Ini sangat relevan dengan apa yang saya cari.
|
Saya sepakat dengan artikel ini benar-benar masuk akal dan mudah dipahami.
|
Sungguh menginspirasi! Saya akan membaca lebih lanjut tentang topik
ini. |
Informasi ini sangat berguna! Saya berharap ada lebih banyak
artikel seperti ini di masa mendatang. |
Sungguh luar biasa membaca artikel ini. Saya akan kembali untuk membaca lebih banyak lagi.
|
Terima kasih semua informasi yang telah dibagikan di artikel ini.
Ini benar-benar berharga. |
Hebat sekali! Artikel ini membantu saya memahami topik yang sebelumnya sulit saya pahami.
|
Sungguh menarik bagaimana Anda menjelaskan hal ini dengan cara yang sangat mudah dipahami.
|
Artikel ini layak untuk dibaca! Saya akan menyimpannya untuk referensi di masa depan. |
Sangat mengapresiasi usaha yang Anda lakukan dalam menulis artikel ini.
Ini sangat membantu banyak orang! |
Jangan berhenti berbagi konten yang luar biasa seperti ini!
Saya pasti akan sering kembali ke blog ini. |
Sangat informatif! Saya telah belajar banyak dari artikel
ini. |
Informasi ini sangat relevan dengan apa yang saya
cari. Terima kasih telah membagikannya! |
Sangat bermanfaat! Saya tidak sabar untuk membaca lebih
banyak artikel dari Anda. |
Saya mendapatkan banyak wawasan! Terima kasih telah berbagi
pengetahuan ini dengan kami. |
Artikel yang luar biasa! Saya ingin membaca lebih banyak
tentang topik ini. |
Saya mengapresiasi waktu dan usaha yang Anda luangkan untuk menulis artikel yang berkualitas ini.
|
Saya pasti akan menyebarkan artikel ini kepada teman-teman saya!
Ini benar-benar berharga. |
Tulisan ini begitu inspiratif! Saya menantikan lebih banyak artikel seperti ini.
|
Terima kasih telah membuat artikel ini. Ini benar-benar membantu saya dalam
banyak hal. |
Saya suka bagaimana Anda membahas ini! |
Sungguh menarik membaca artikel ini. Saya akan sering kembali ke sini.
|
Artikel ini benar-benar bermanfaat! Terima kasih sudah
berbagi! |
Saya tidak pernah bosan membaca blog ini. |
Sungguh konten yang luar biasa! |
Benar-benar menginspirasi! Saya sangat menyukainya. |
Sangat mengesankan bagaimana Anda menjelaskan sesuatu dengan begitu jelas.
|
Artikel ini benar-benar luar biasa! |
Saya menghargai waktu dan usaha yang Anda luangkan untuk
membuat artikel yang sangat bermanfaat ini. |
Blog ini benar-benar memberikan wawasan yang inspiratif! Saya menantikan lebih banyak artikel seperti ini.
|
Saya sangat menikmati Artikel ini memberikan banyak informasi yang bernilai.
Terima kasih! |
Akhirnya saya menemukan! Artikel ini sangat membantu saya dalam
memahami topik ini. |
Konten ini luar biasa! Saya akan membagikannya kepada teman-teman saya.
|
Terima kasih atas artikel ini! Saya tidak sabar untuk
membaca lebih banyak dari blog ini. |
Sangat membantu! Terima kasih telah berbagi wawasan yang sangat berguna ini.
|
Saya sangat menghargai bagaimana Anda menjelaskan topik ini dengan begitu mudah dimengerti.
|
Sangat direkomendasikan! Saya akan menyimpannya untuk referensi di masa depan.
|
Saya menghargai kerja keras Anda dalam menulis artikel ini.
Ini benar-benar membantu banyak orang! |
Jangan berhenti berbagi konten luar biasa seperti ini! Saya
pasti akan sering kembali ke blog ini. |
Benar-benar mendidik! Saya telah belajar banyak dari artikel ini.
|
Sangat inspiratif! Saya tidak sabar untuk membaca lebih banyak artikel
dari Anda. |
Saya telah belajar banyak! Terima kasih telah berbagi pengetahuan ini
dengan kami. |
Saya suka bagaimana Anda membahas ini! |
Sungguh menarik membaca artikel ini. Saya akan sering kembali ke sini.
|
Artikel ini benar-benar bermanfaat! Terima kasih sudah berbagi!
|
Saya selalu menantikan artikel baru di blog ini.
|
Terima kasih telah berbagi hal ini! |
Sungguh bermanfaat! Saya sangat menyukainya.
|
Saya suka bagaimana Anda menjelaskan sesuatu dengan begitu jelas.
|
Saya berharap lebih banyak artikel seperti ini! |
Saya menghargai waktu dan usaha yang Anda luangkan untuk membuat artikel
yang sangat bermanfaat ini. |
Saya akan menyebarluaskan artikel ini kepada teman-teman saya!
Ini benar-benar berharga. |
Saya benar-benar terkesan! Artikel ini memberikan banyak wawasan yang saya butuhkan. |
Benar-benar informatif! Terima kasih telah membagikan informasi yang sangat menarik ini.
|
Sungguh membuka wawasan! Terima kasih sudah berbagi. |
Saya mendapatkan pemahaman baru! |
Sangat inspiratif! Saya tidak sabar untuk membaca lebih banyak
artikel seperti ini. |
Saya tidak tahu sebelumnya tentang ini! |
Blog ini memiliki konten berkualitas! |
Sungguh artikel yang bagus! |
Saya akan menyebarluaskan artikel ini! |
Saya mendapatkan banyak ide dari ini! |
Tulisannya benar-benar berkualitas! |
Sungguh menyenangkan membaca blog ini! |
Sangat membantu memahami konsep ini! |
Saya tidak sabar menunggu artikel berikutnya! |
Sungguh tulisan yang menarik! |
Terima kasih atas artikel yang sangat baik ini! |
Tulisan ini benar-benar menginspirasi! |
Sangat rinci dan mudah dipahami! |
Artikel seperti ini benar-benar dibutuhkan! |
Sungguh bacaan yang menarik! |
Saya ingin membaca lebih banyak tentang topik ini! |
Saya senang akhirnya menemukan blog ini! |
Saya ingin tahu lebih banyak dari Anda! |
I am really inspired along with your writing skills and also with the structure on your blog. Is that this a paid subject or did you modify it your self? Anyway keep up the nice high quality writing, it is uncommon to look a nice blog like this one today!
I’m really inspired along with your writing skills as neatly as
with the layout to your blog. Is that this a paid subject
or did you modify it your self? Either way keep up the nice high
quality writing, it’s uncommon to look a nice blog like this one
these days. Snipfeed!
olympe casino cresus: olympe casino en ligne – olympe casino
kamagra livraison 24h: Achetez vos kamagra medicaments – kamagra gel
pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es: Meilleure pharmacie en ligne – Pharmacie sans ordonnance pharmafst.com
Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher: Cialis sans ordonnance 24h – Cialis sans ordonnance 24h tadalmed.shop
https://pharmafst.shop/# pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es pharmacie en ligne pharmacie en ligne pharmafst.shop
Kamagra pharmacie en ligne Kamagra pharmacie en ligne or kamagra en ligne
https://cse.google.co.im/url?q=https://kamagraprix.com kamagra 100mg prix
kamagra en ligne kamagra gel and Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher
Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance – Achat Cialis en ligne fiable tadalmed.shop
pharmacie en ligne france fiable pharmacie en ligne livraison europe or Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
http://transfer-talk.herokuapp.com/l?l=http://pharmafst.com acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable and pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance п»їpharmacie en ligne france
kamagra en ligne Kamagra pharmacie en ligne or kamagra gel
https://weberu.ru/redirect/?url=http://kamagraprix.shop kamagra 100mg prix
kamagra gel achat kamagra and Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher kamagra 100mg prix
Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne: Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne – Tadalafil sans ordonnance en ligne tadalmed.shop
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – pharmacie en ligne livraison europe pharmafst.com
trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie: Pharmacie en ligne France – Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe pharmafst.com
https://tadalmed.shop/# cialis prix
Acheter Cialis 20 mg pas cher Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance tadalmed.com
Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance: Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance – Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
Tadalafil achat en ligne cialis sans ordonnance or Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher
http://xl-chat.ru/go.php?url=http://tadalmed.com Cialis sans ordonnance pas cher
Achat Cialis en ligne fiable Tadalafil 20 mg prix en pharmacie and Cialis sans ordonnance 24h Cialis generique prix
vente de mГ©dicament en ligne: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance pharmafst.com
Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher: Kamagra Commander maintenant – Acheter Kamagra site fiable
http://kamagraprix.com/# kamagra en ligne
Kamagra pharmacie en ligne Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher or kamagra livraison 24h
https://www.google.com.lb/url?sa=t&url=https://kamagraprix.shop Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher
achat kamagra Acheter Kamagra site fiable and kamagra 100mg prix Acheter Kamagra site fiable
trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacie en ligne livraison europe pharmafst.com
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance pharmacie en ligne livraison europe or pharmacie en ligne livraison europe
http://clients1.google.com.vn/url?q=https://pharmafst.com pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
pharmacie en ligne france fiable Pharmacie Internationale en ligne and pharmacie en ligne livraison europe vente de mГ©dicament en ligne
acheter kamagra site fiable: kamagra pas cher – Acheter Kamagra site fiable
http://kamagraprix.com/# Achetez vos kamagra medicaments
pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es: Meilleure pharmacie en ligne – trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie pharmafst.com
kamagra 100mg prix Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher or acheter kamagra site fiable
https://www.google.com.nf/url?q=http://kamagraprix.shop kamagra livraison 24h
kamagra en ligne kamagra 100mg prix and Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher Achetez vos kamagra medicaments
pharmacie en ligne france fiable: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher pharmafst.com
Cialis sans ordonnance 24h: cialis sans ordonnance – Cialis generique prix tadalmed.shop
Acheter Cialis: Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance – Cialis generique prix tadalmed.shop
https://pharmafst.com/# pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
achat kamagra kamagra gel acheter kamagra site fiable
pharmacie en ligne livraison europe: Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h – pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmafst.com
kamagra gel Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher or Acheter Kamagra site fiable
https://maps.google.co.mz/url?q=https://kamagraprix.com acheter kamagra site fiable
kamagra pas cher acheter kamagra site fiable and kamagra pas cher kamagra 100mg prix
pharmacie en ligne france pas cher: pharmacie en ligne – vente de mГ©dicament en ligne pharmafst.com
https://pharmafst.com/# Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
pharmacie en ligne fiable vente de mГ©dicament en ligne or pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique
http://www.rms-republic.com/cgi-bin/jump/frame.cgi?url=pharmafst.com&referer=www.rms-republic.com pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
Pharmacie Internationale en ligne acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance and pharmacie en ligne fiable pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale
kamagra gel acheter kamagra site fiable or kamagra en ligne
http://www.flugzeugmarkt.eu/url?q=https://kamagraprix.shop Kamagra Commander maintenant
[url=http://hlsw.org/ajax/news_slides/default.php?link=https://kamagraprix.shop]achat kamagra[/url] acheter kamagra site fiable and [url=https://www.eco-worthy.com/community/xenforum/users/234751]kamagra 100mg prix[/url] kamagra gel
Cialis sans ordonnance 24h: Cialis sans ordonnance 24h – Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
pharmacie en ligne france pas cher pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale pharmafst.shop
pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique: pharmacie en ligne pas cher – pharmacie en ligne france fiable pharmafst.com
https://tadalmed.com/# Achat Cialis en ligne fiable
Cialis generique prix: cialis generique – Cialis en ligne tadalmed.shop
kamagra en ligne kamagra pas cher kamagra livraison 24h
Kamagra pharmacie en ligne: Kamagra pharmacie en ligne – kamagra livraison 24h
acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance: Livraison rapide – pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance pharmafst.com
https://kamagraprix.com/# kamagra 100mg prix
Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher kamagra en ligne or kamagra oral jelly
https://maps.google.bj/url?q=https://kamagraprix.com achat kamagra
Kamagra pharmacie en ligne Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher and kamagra gel achat kamagra
Cialis generique prix: Cialis generique prix – Cialis en ligne tadalmed.shop
kamagra en ligne Acheter Kamagra site fiable or Kamagra Commander maintenant
https://clients1.google.com.sa/url?q=https://kamagraprix.shop acheter kamagra site fiable
kamagra gel kamagra livraison 24h and Kamagra pharmacie en ligne kamagra gel
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale or pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance
https://images.google.ne/url?q=https://pharmafst.com trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie
pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacie en ligne france fiable and pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es
kamagra en ligne: kamagra en ligne – kamagra pas cher
pharmacie en ligne france livraison belgique Medicaments en ligne livres en 24h pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es pharmafst.shop
kamagra pas cher: acheter kamagra site fiable – Kamagra Commander maintenant
http://pharmafst.com/# п»їpharmacie en ligne france
kamagra pas cher: kamagra livraison 24h – Acheter Kamagra site fiable
https://pharmafst.com/# pharmacie en ligne fiable
Kamagra Commander maintenant: kamagra en ligne – achat kamagra
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable or acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
https://maps.google.fm/url?sa=t&url=https://pharmafst.com pharmacie en ligne pas cher
pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale pharmacie en ligne livraison europe and pharmacie en ligne avec ordonnance acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
https://pharmafst.shop/# Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable
pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es: pharmacie en ligne – Pharmacie sans ordonnance pharmafst.com
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance: pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance – Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable pharmafst.com
https://tadalmed.com/# Tadalafil achat en ligne
Tadalafil achat en ligne: cialis generique – Acheter Viagra Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
pharmacie en ligne pharmacie en ligne france pas cher or pharmacie en ligne pas cher
http://linkpage.biz/?pharmafst.com pharmacie en ligne france pas cher
pharmacie en ligne Pharmacie Internationale en ligne and Pharmacie sans ordonnance acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance
https://tadalmed.com/# cialis generique
Kamagra Commander maintenant: achat kamagra – kamagra en ligne
cialis sans ordonnance: Tadalafil achat en ligne – Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
Acheter Kamagra site fiable: Kamagra Commander maintenant – Kamagra Oral Jelly pas cher
Acheter Cialis: cialis prix – Pharmacie en ligne Cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
pharmacie en ligne france fiable pharmacie en ligne pas cher pharmacies en ligne certifiГ©es pharmafst.shop
http://pharmafst.com/# pharmacie en ligne
Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance: Cialis generique prix – Tadalafil 20 mg prix sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
Pharmacie Internationale en ligne pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale or Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
https://images.google.co.uz/url?q=http://pharmafst.com Pharmacie en ligne livraison Europe
pharmacie en ligne sans ordonnance trouver un mГ©dicament en pharmacie and pharmacie en ligne france livraison internationale Pharmacie Internationale en ligne
Achat Cialis en ligne fiable: cialis prix – cialis sans ordonnance tadalmed.shop
kamagra pas cher: acheter kamagra site fiable – kamagra livraison 24h
acheter mГ©dicament en ligne sans ordonnance: Achat mГ©dicament en ligne fiable – pharmacie en ligne france pas cher pharmafst.com
https://kamagraprix.shop/# Achetez vos kamagra medicaments
http://expressrxcanada.com/# 77 canadian pharmacy
mexican online pharmacy: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – mexico drug stores pharmacies
MedicineFromIndia: indian pharmacy – Medicine From India
canadian family pharmacy: best canadian pharmacy – canada drugs
RxExpressMexico mexican rx online mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://medicinefromindia.com/# indian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy victoza: Buy medicine from Canada – canadian world pharmacy
Medicine From India: medicine courier from India to USA – medicine courier from India to USA
mexico pharmacy order online: RxExpressMexico – Rx Express Mexico
http://expressrxcanada.com/# best canadian pharmacy to buy from
Medicine From India: MedicineFromIndia – Medicine From India
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: Rx Express Mexico – Rx Express Mexico
reputable indian pharmacies top online pharmacy india or indian pharmacy paypal
https://forum.turkerview.com/proxy.php?link=https://medicinefromindia.com top 10 online pharmacy in india
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india reputable indian pharmacies and best india pharmacy top 10 pharmacies in india
http://rxexpressmexico.com/# Rx Express Mexico
precription drugs from canada Buy medicine from Canada ordering drugs from canada
indian pharmacy online: indian pharmacy – Medicine From India
my canadian pharmacy: canadian drug prices – canadian king pharmacy
cheapest online pharmacy india indian pharmacy paypal or indian pharmacy
https://www.google.fi/url?sa=t&url=https://medicinefromindia.com п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india
top 10 online pharmacy in india Online medicine order and mail order pharmacy india india pharmacy mail order
canadian pharmacy ratings: Canadian pharmacy shipping to USA – canadian pharmacy india
canadapharmacyonline legit maple leaf pharmacy in canada or canadian pharmacy mall
http://www.mvbcwm.com/System/Login.asp?id=40305&Referer=http://expressrxcanada.com best canadian pharmacy to buy from
canadian pharmacy no scripts trusted canadian pharmacy and canadian 24 hour pharmacy cheapest pharmacy canada
http://rxexpressmexico.com/# mexican online pharmacy
RxExpressMexico: mexico drug stores pharmacies – mexican rx online
canadian pharmacies online: Express Rx Canada – my canadian pharmacy review
legitimate canadian online pharmacies Express Rx Canada certified canadian international pharmacy
mexican rx online: RxExpressMexico – mexican online pharmacy
RxExpressMexico: mexico pharmacies prescription drugs – Rx Express Mexico
https://medicinefromindia.com/# indian pharmacy online shopping
mexican online pharmacy: mexican rx online – mexico drug stores pharmacies
best online pharmacy india indian pharmacy paypal or cheapest online pharmacy india
https://www.google.nl/url?sa=t&url=https://medicinefromindia.com cheapest online pharmacy india
indian pharmacy paypal cheapest online pharmacy india and indian pharmacy online pharmacy india
indian pharmacy paypal reputable indian pharmacies or top 10 online pharmacy in india
https://toolbarqueries.google.com.bz/url?sa=t&url=https://medicinefromindia.com mail order pharmacy india
indian pharmacy online pharmacy india and indian pharmacies safe reputable indian online pharmacy
canadian online drugstore canadian drug prices drugs from canada
canadian pharmacy prices: ExpressRxCanada – legal to buy prescription drugs from canada
safe reliable canadian pharmacy: Express Rx Canada – best canadian pharmacy to order from
http://rxexpressmexico.com/# RxExpressMexico
mexican online pharmacy: Rx Express Mexico – mexican online pharmacy
77 canadian pharmacy Canadian pharmacy shipping to USA canadian discount pharmacy
indian pharmacy online: indian pharmacy online shopping – indian pharmacy online
https://rxexpressmexico.com/# mexico pharmacy order online
Rx Express Mexico: buying from online mexican pharmacy – Rx Express Mexico
indian pharmacy online top online pharmacy india or india pharmacy mail order
https://www.veropharm.ru/redirect/?url=http://medicinefromindia.com online shopping pharmacy india
top 10 pharmacies in india top 10 pharmacies in india and online shopping pharmacy india buy prescription drugs from india
indian pharmacies safe indian pharmacy online or online pharmacy india
https://maps.google.com.gi/url?q=http://medicinefromindia.com indian pharmacy online
india online pharmacy world pharmacy india and india pharmacy buy prescription drugs from india
Rx Express Mexico mexico drug stores pharmacies mexican online pharmacy
http://expressrxcanada.com/# canadapharmacyonline com
mexico pharmacies prescription drugs: RxExpressMexico – mexico pharmacy order online
пин ап казино официальный сайт: пин ап зеркало – пинап казино
vavada вход: вавада зеркало – вавада казино
пин ап вход: pin up вход – пин ап казино официальный сайт
pin-up casino giris: pin up casino – pin-up casino giris
https://pinuprus.pro/# пин ап зеркало
пин ап казино пин ап казино официальный сайт пин ап казино официальный сайт
пин ап казино официальный сайт: пин ап вход – pin up вход
пинап казино: пин ап зеркало – пин ап вход
https://pinupaz.top/# pin up casino
pinup az: pin up casino – pin up casino
vavada casino vavada casino вавада казино
pin up: pin up az – pin-up
https://pinuprus.pro/# pin up вход
пин ап зеркало: пинап казино – пин ап казино официальный сайт
пин ап вход пин ап зеркало пин ап казино